🌱 Evidence of Learning: How Student Portfolios Support Better Planning
- vanessa speigle
- 2 days ago
- 3 min read
Many teachers collect student work every day: notebooks, exit tickets, drafts, reflections and still feel unsure about what to do next.
The problem usually isn’t effort. It’s not a lack of data. And it’s not that teachers aren’t paying attention.
The problem is that evidence is often gathered after learning, instead of during it and portfolios become storage spaces rather than planning tools.
When evidence is disconnected from reflection, it doesn’t inform instruction. It just accumulates.
Shifting the Question: What Is Evidence of Learning For?
In many classrooms, evidence of learning is treated as proof, something to confirm whether students “got it” once the lesson is over.
Finnish-inspired classrooms approach evidence differently.
Evidence isn’t collected to judge learning. It’s gathered to understand thinking.
The purpose of evidence is not to finalize decisions; it’s to guide them.
When students reflect during learning, the evidence that emerges becomes:
more authentic
more useful
less overwhelming for teachers
more meaningful for students
This is where portfolios begin to matter not as finished products, but as living records of learning in motion.
Portfolios as Planning Tools (Not Collections)
A student portfolio is most powerful when it answers one simple question:
What is this student thinking right now?
When portfolios are built through reflection:
Teachers don’t need to “add” assessment
Planning becomes more responsive
Students understand why their work matters
Instead of organizing work by subject or unit, portfolios begin to reveal:
patterns of understanding
recurring misconceptions
confidence shifts
emerging questions
And that’s where planning clarity comes from.
Research on formative assessment consistently shows that instruction improves when teachers adjust teaching during learning, based on student thinking not after grading (Black & Wiliam).
Five Ways Evidence from Portfolios Can Shape Planning
These ideas offer new ways to use portfolio evidence without increasing workload.
1. Planning from Patterns, Not Pieces
Rather than responding to individual artifacts, pause and scan several student reflections at once.
Look for:
common questions
shared confusions
repeated strategies
similar confidence levels
Planning doesn’t require fixing everything just choosing one pattern to address next.
2. Letting Students Surface What Matters
When students select their own portfolio artifacts, they reveal what they believe counts as learning.
Their choices often show:
what they value
where they feel growth
what they’re uncertain about
This information is far more useful than a completed worksheet and it tells teachers where to focus next.
3. Using Mid-Lesson Evidence to Adjust Pace
Evidence doesn’t need to come at the end of a lesson.
Short reflection pauses, even two minutes, can reveal whether to:
slow down
move on
regroup students
revisit one key idea
This reduces re-teaching later and prevents learning gaps from widening.
4. Tracking Growth Over Time, Not Perfection
One of the most powerful portfolio entries is a comparison:
earlier thinking vs. current thinking
first attempt vs. revised work
When students reflect on change, teachers gain insight into:
what helped learning stick
which strategies worked
where support mattered most
This shifts planning away from grades and toward development.
5. Planning with Students, Not Just for Them
When students regularly reflect, they begin to anticipate next steps themselves.
Teachers can plan with student thinking by asking:
“What are you ready for next?”
“What do you want to practice more?”
“What still feels unclear?”
Planning becomes a shared process not a guessing game.
A Gentle Reminder About Ownership
Portfolios work best when students build them.
The teacher’s role is not to curate, organize, or perfect portfolios but to design reflection moments that allow meaningful evidence to emerge.
When students gather their own artifacts:
portfolios become personal
reflection becomes purposeful
learning becomes visible
And teachers gain clarity without carrying more.
A Reflection to Pause With
Continue the Conversation
This blog builds on the deep dive video exploring how evidence of learning supports planning and student portfolios.
If you’d like to see these ideas in action with classroom examples and visual tools you can explore:
the full Starting Student Portfolios
reflection-based templates at the Rekla Store.
They’re designed to support you not add pressure.
Research Reference
Black, P., & Wiliam, D. Inside the Black Box: Raising Standards Through Classroom Assessment.
Comments